I load curtain-side trailers and fridges. In a fridge there are no straps at all — loading boards against the walls, and the wall is expected to do the work. In a curtainsider there are straps and lashing points, and the sheet on the side, which everybody treats as a wall until the first time a pallet leans on it.
I am not a load-securing engineer and this is not a lashing course. What follows is the published arithmetic and what it says about the two trailers I actually pull.
The forces are fixed, and forward is the hard one
The European rules put numbers on what a load must survive. Directive 2014/47/EU, Article 13 and Annex III, requires securing against 0.8 times the weight of the cargo in the direction of travel, 0.5 times sideways, and 0.5 times rearward. The same three figures appear in the Commission's cargo securing guidelines as design accelerations: 0.8 g forward, 0.5 g sideways.
The forward figure is the one that decides most loads, and it is not a gentle number. On a 24-tonne payload it is 19.2 tonnes of force that the combination of body, friction and lashings has to hold.
The guidelines also publish what a certified body is tested to. A box body built to EN 12642 XL has side walls tested to 40 per cent of the payload and a headboard tested to 50 per cent — 0.5 P. A body built to L has side walls tested to 30 per cent.
So on the same 24 tonnes: the XL headboard is good for 12 tonnes forward, and the requirement is 19.2. The rest has to come from somewhere else.
Where the rest comes from: friction, and only friction
The headboard does not carry the load. Friction between the pallets and the deck carries the load, and the headboard catches what friction does not.
The guidelines give the working figures. For dry, clean, uncontaminated surfaces the friction factor between sawn wood and plywood is around 0.45; between a plastic pallet and a plywood deck it is 0.20. If the deck is not swept, or there is frost or snow on it, the guidance is blunt: do not use a friction factor above 0.2.
Run the numbers on 24 tonnes, load hard against an XL headboard, dry plywood deck:
`` forward requirement 0.8 x 24 t 19.2 t friction, 0.45 x 24 t 10.8 t XL headboard, 0.5 x 24 t 12.0 t friction plus headboard 22.8 t passes ``
Same load, same truck, a fortnight later, deck damp and cold at 0.2:
`` friction, 0.20 x 24 t 4.8 t friction plus headboard 16.8 t fails, by 2.4 t ``
Nothing about the load changed. The weather changed the friction, and the combination that passed in the morning does not pass in the afternoon.
Now the version that happens at a loading bay with a lazy last pallet: a gap of half a metre to the headboard. The headboard no longer touches the load, so the 12 tonnes it could have taken never enters the sum.
`` dry deck, gap to the headboard: friction alone 10.8 t fails, by 8.4 t ``
That is the whole argument for pushing the load forward before you close the doors. Tidiness has nothing to do with it; the question is whether a certified component takes any of the force at all.
Why strapping a pallet down is often the weakest option
A strap over the top of a load — a top-over lashing — works by pressing the load onto the deck. The force it presses with is the tension the ratchet leaves behind, not the lashing capacity printed on the label. The lashing capacity is what the strap can transmit in a straight pull, and it is several times larger than the pretension; a strap labelled 1,600 daN lashing capacity typically leaves about 400 daN of pretension at 50 daN of hand force.
Two consequences follow, and they explain most of the arguments at a loading bay.
The first is that the clamp is only part of the tension. It is the tension multiplied by the sine of the angle to the deck. At 90 degrees you get all of it; at 45 degrees 71 per cent; at 30 degrees half; at 20 degrees a third. A strap run almost flat along the load is doing very little pressing and a lot of pulling sideways against itself.
The second is that the clamp only helps through friction. The extra resistance a top-over lashing adds is the clamp multiplied by the friction factor. On a dry wooden deck that is a useful multiplication. On a wet or icy deck it is a small one, which is why the guidance for low-friction surfaces moves to blocking and form-fit rather than more straps.
The curtain, specifically
A curtain-sided trailer is a body with a roof, a floor, a headboard, posts and laths, and sheets on the sides. The sheets are weather protection. The guidelines treat the side walls of a curtain-sided vehicle as exactly that — and an L-rated body's side walls, where they are rated at all, are rated at 30 per cent of the payload, against a sideways requirement of 50 per cent.
The load-bearing parts are the ones with a certificate: the headboard, the posts, the laths, the floor, the lashing points. That certificate is the document an inspector may ask for, and it is the reason a trailer's data plate matters more than the number of straps hanging in the curtain.
On a fridge the position is different in form and identical in principle. There are no straps because the body is built to take the load through loading boards and walls and a floor designed for it. The boards are not a per-board rating you can add up; they are part of the body's certified resistance. Once a pallet sits away from the boards, the body is not holding it and nothing else is.
What an inspector actually does
The check is defined in Article 13 of the directive and detailed in Annex III, and it is not a judgement about whether the load looks tidy. It is four actions: look at the load and the equipment, measure tension where a gauge is available, recalculate the securing against the requirement, and read the certificates for the body and the lashings.
The two thresholds worth remembering from the scoring table are a distance of more than 15 cm to a wall you are relying on for blocking, and a calculated securing below two thirds of the requirement. The first is why a load is pushed forward. The second is the difference between a defect that is corrected on the spot and one that stops the vehicle.
What I do before the doors close
1. Push it forward. The headboard is the largest certified component on the trailer and it only works in contact. 2. Fill the gaps. Blocking between pallets stops the whole row moving as one unit; empty space in the middle turns twelve pallets into twelve projectiles. 3. Look at the deck. Water, frost and grit on the floor are a friction problem, not a cleaning problem, and no number of straps fixes a slide that starts at 0.2. 4. Count the straps in the right direction. Forward restraint is the requirement that fails first, and it is the one most loads have least of.
None of this makes a curtain into a wall, and no loading board becomes a lashing. It is a matter of knowing which component is holding the load and making sure the load is actually touching it.
Related
- Five kinds of freight, five different jobs — why a curtain, a fridge and a container ask different things of a driver.
- What GDP training means when you're carrying pharmaceutical goods — the checks that apply on top of the load itself.
Sources
- Directive 2014/47/EU, Article 13 and Annex III
- European Commission, Cargo securing for road transport — 2014 European best practices guidelines
- EN 12195-1:2010 and EN 12642, as reproduced in those guidelines